“Whatever this is it is horrible and – annoyingly – horribly compelling”
“How do I review that?”, I asked my unsuspecting friend once the thing was finally over. I’d dragged him to to The Yard Theatre to spend 70 minutes watching the Philosophy of the World. The 70 minutes were not enjoyable but were utterly utterly grim. I left with a literal and figurative headache – knowing that that was exactly what Nora Alexander, Dora Lynn and Kat Cory – collectively known as IN BED WITH MY BROTHER – wanted.
The thing starts with the three women walking on, telling us the play will be linear and that they are going to follow a script. Disconcerting. Their ‘script’ starts as stage directions/instructions that flash onto a curtain with a horrendous thud. Apparently we’re watching the story of The Shaggs. Thud. The Shaggs were three sisters. Thud. Their father had a palm reading that said his daughters were destined for fame. Thud. So he’s going to turn them into a band. Thud. The sisters are given names, told to put on tshirts, rehearse in the basement and do calisthenics. Which they do – again and again. With horrifically loud thuds.
The calisthenics and rehearsals finally end when The Shagg’s father dies and they exercise their ‘freewill’, grotesquely guzzling coke. But their father comes back (as a ghost maybe? God knows) and The Shaggs are forced to put back on their tshirts.
The Shaggs at this point become vile as they repeatedly kill their father (who is also the stage manager Nigel). They move around the stage strangling beating kicking strangling beating kicking. The audience taste Nigel’s blood. It is gruelling. Distasteful. Rank. Eventually Nigel (the stage manager) calls his safe word and the women step out of The Shagg’s story and back into their own.
One delivers a long desperate wail of a monologue, one thrashes on the drums and the other draws a diagram on a blackboard. By the end they are all topless. The monologue weaves together the stories of The Shaggs, IN BED WITH MY BROTHER and Valerie Solanas to show how women’s stories get crushed and stomped on by controlling men who neuter them and tell them they are shit. Between the pained shouts, half of which we can’t hear, we are told that art is messy and unlikeable and that “YOU CAN’T PLEASE EVERYONE IN THE WORLD” and that capitalism is to blame and AI is destroying art. I guess we should be angry and scared.
Eventually the tirade ends. And Nigel walks back on stage to say he’ll “be selling tshirts in the foyer after the show”. There is extraordinary relief that it is over. Every moment is made to be broken. It is hard work being in the audience when you feel this hated.
IN BED WITH MY BROTHER don’t care what the critics think. But I thought the idea became the play and cannibalised the story. We got told to be angry by the actors as opposed to feeling anger on behalf of the characters they portrayed. At one point we – the poor unsuspecting audience – were told to throw coke cans at the three women. I did and felt nothing but ambivalence; wouldn’t it have been better if I did or didn’t want to. Despite this I still feel the effects of some strange Stockholm Syndrome. This theatre was never about The Shagg’s or their story it was always about the three women behind IN BED WITH MY BROTHER. And they are constantly outstanding. Their artistry is undeniable.
Not all theatre can be like this. We would simply stop going. I think I hated it. But I would still, on balance, tell you go to the Yard Theatre and experience the force of these three women. Fill yourself up with disgust and anger. Feel sick. Feel something. Let your ears bleed.
Philosophy of the World is on at The Yard Theatre until 1st August. Tickets are available here.

