This dark comedy about a psychotic break lacks polish, but delivers laughter and pathos
As the audience enter the Lio & Unicorn Theatre, they’re invited to “sit wherever you like” by The Devil (Campbell Maddox), who is seething at the absence of his co-star: God (Neo Jelfs). Audience members chit-chat with the literal embodiment of evil, who narrates his passion for controlled chaos, apologises for profanity in the show programme, and reminisces about performing at the Edinburgh Fringe. The show proper begins with a churlish God rocking up late, before teenager Gabe (Noah Edmondson), hallucinating both religious figures, enters his bedroom. Much of the comedy comes from God and The Devil bickering like an old married couple, juxtaposed against Gabe’s real-life teenage woes. But God, The Devil and Me also has a lot of heart, and a surprisingly sensitive and affecting portrayal of mental health in crisis.
As a theatrical route into discussing psychosis, it’s strikingly inventive. There are genuinely funny barbs thrown out by both hallucinations, with Maddox’s camp and needy Devil a highlight. But as the narrative progresses, and Gabe’s life becomes more stressful, the hallucinations take a darker turn. They erode Gabe’s trust in his family and friends, stoking paranoia and delusions of grandeur. Director and writer Fionnuala Donnelly’s real-life experience of a schizoaffective diagnosis adds a sharp edge to the events unfolding on stage.
The quality of the acting varies between cast members, and there’s a lack of polish in places: some jokes are overexplained, flattening what should be funny offhand remarks into repetitive slogs; a laugh track introduced halfway through never pays off. But God, The Devil and Me still lands with both laughs and pathos. Most resonant are moments where the audience sees Gabe’s breakdown through others’ eyes, stripping away the hallucinations entirely. A memorable argument with his mother (played by writer Fionnuala Donnelly) sees God and the Devil whistle to obscure attempts at bridge-building, become increasingly irate with one another, and physically prod Gabe into lashing out.
A second act psychotic break, leading to a stint in hospital, dials down the laughs and replaces them with the power of human connection. Gabe’s burgeoning friendship with fellow patient Hannah (Maisie Lee Mead), and words of kindness from a nurse on the ward (Neo Jelfs) are touching. But an emotional revelation during a family therapy session tips into cliché, feeling unearned (appropriately enough, this is the commentary God gives from inside Gabe’s head – but self-awareness doesn’t make it less true).
God, The Devil and Me is rough around the edges, but there’s a lot to admire. A strong epilogue – with God and The Devil riffing on organised religion and the Bible – sends the audience away happy, but it’s the nuanced, touching portrayal of psychosis that lingers once they’re out the door.
God, The Devil and Me plays at the Lion & Unicorn Theatre until 10th January, at 7:30 each evening. Tickets can be purchased here.









