We sat down for a quick chat with Emma Bentley about her upcoming project.
How did your own experiences working in cafés shape the emotional world and authenticity of the characters in the supermodel in the caff?
Working in third places – a cafe or a restaurant for a long period of time – you get to see people in all different moods. If you have a good relationship with the person and they’re open to an extent you’ll probably find out why, working in service is of course a kind of therapy isn’t it. So then you get the back story. Sometimes though, you have the scintillating characters that come in that you never quite know why they behave in certain ways, and you wonder, wonder what’s going on, why they’re grumpy, or always happy, or why one day their eyes look a bit red.
As the piece grew from a scratch-night monologue into a full solo show, what surprised you most about how the four women’s stories began to intertwine?
I wrote the play over 2 years ago, let me try to cast my mind back. The characters are so fully themselves to me now it’s hard to think back to when they were just a glimmer at a kitchen table. I think I remember being like “Yesss ohmygod yess!” when I realised there was a connection between Janey (a woman experiencing homelessness who is begging in the caff) and Bea (the supermodel who is coming out to her best childhood friend). That was really satisfying as a writer as I realised that it meant that I could really show how both the characters – no matter their backgrounds or privilege in certain circles – could befriend anyone. And also that sad thing of transient city relationships where if you haven’t seen someone for x years, you might not recognise them instantly because you’ve moved on and changed so much and so have they.
The play touches on queerness, class and financial insecurity—what felt important to you about exploring these themes through the very everyday setting of a greasy spoon?
Queerness was an important one as – I don’t know if this is like an actual thing or not – but as caffs are caught up in 90s nostalgia, I’ve often assumed that they are not always the most welcoming of spaces to a queer gal like me. However, in reality, I think that is actually rarely the case and so I wanted the first character the audience meet to be Nessa-wearing her Fred Perry, clearly gay and at home in the caff. In terms of financial insecurity, although I don’t think the play does it in words, I basically wanted to bang the drum of like “aren’t these spaces frickin amazing?!” You can get a massive plate of food and a drink and not feel like you’ve been robbed on the way out. Bea, the supermodel, talks about them being places where you won’t be judged for doing anything (“Like fuuuck, no one even smokes anymore.”) And there’s something about that that I enjoy. Middle class coffee shops have become places of slouchy high fashion, work calls, £7 iced matcha lattes. In a greasy spoon you can turn up however you want.
How has your involvement with Cardboard Citizens influenced your creative practice, and did it shift anything in how you approached this show?
I only became a member of Citz three months ago so I’m actually excited to see how it influences the creation of my next play. It’s honestly been such a nice space to be creative in a very relaxed and non career progression-y kind of way. I was missing the joy of being an artist and it’s given me a space to breathe, to be vulnerable. Doing More Than One Story at the Trafalgar Theatre (I was asked to read one of the monologues from an anthology of plays that they have produced with Nick Hern Books) was pretty influential. Listening to all the monologues that have echoes of themes and even stories that are in supermodel, and hearing the audience’s response, just backed up the thought of “okay I’m not crazy, not everyone wants to just see plays about wealthy people, this could work.” The prologue which is written by Michael Sheen (read brilliantly by Paterson Joseph on the night) is extremely powerful too. It lifts a veil on how, unless we use our courage and power to talk about poverty, homelessness and inequity on stage, our voices risk being silenced. Go buy the book.
After such a strong response at The Hope Theatre, what does it feel like to bring the piece into a new space and new audiences at The Cockpit
Buzzing is one word! I’d been to see a show at The Cockpit years ago – HOT (Helen or Troy) (which was actually made by Amy Clare Tasker who is the director of Theatre Maker, the arm of The Cockpit that we are under for the run) and I knew it was legendary space. Then returning to meet Dave, the location, the speckled marble doors, the way the bar has all its original 70s style to it, and then the theatre itself is so expansive. We’ll be making full use of the voms and staircases so I can get up close and chat with the audience – one of my favourite things is really being with them. But it’s great because there is so much space, it won’t feel as cramped at The Hope. A relief for us all as I do get quite sweaty.
You’ve said you want audiences to leave with “their cheeks hurting”—what kind of connection or release do you hope this story gives them by the time they step out of the caff?
Connection and release feel like big words! At the beginning of the writing process I set out to write something that ultimately I thought would be a fun night out. I can’t speak on behalf of our audiences but I can say there was a lot of laughter and a lovely shared feeling of buoyancy in the bar after the show – people talking about old service jobs, or a person who reminded them of this character, wondering how the way people move across a room makes them different. I think the show reminds us that our minds are so busy, and often working against our best interests, and in doing so helps us to be a little kinder to ourselves and to others. Because there is ultimately a happy queer ending (I won’t explain how – spoilerzzz) I think there is also the release that if you think you might be gay, but you’re scared to share it with anyone, it’s okay. And it’s also okay to be gay. And it’s also okay to eat! Eat two fried eggs on toast and a shitty coffee. And don’t stress about it.

