REVIEW: Shakespeare’s Cousin

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

This new work explores the life of a lesser-known Elizabethan poet, offering a philosophical analysis of religious persecution under Elizabeth’s rule


Shakespeare’s Cousin, a new work by writer and director Jonathan Moore, explores the life of Robert Southwell–Elizabethan poet and Jesuit priest. Some historians have posited that Southwell was distantly related to William Shakespeare; this play imagines what a relationship between the two authors might have looked like through a series of vignettes depicting Southwell’s experience of religious persecution for his Catholic faith.

Danny Solomon brought Robert Southwell to life with poise and conviction, especially in the moments when Southwell was describing his faith and spiritual inner world. Alex Townson as ‘Sir Oliver’ (Shakespeare’s imagined alias) embodied the famous playwright with a larger-than-life energy. Robin Kingsland as the notorious ‘priest-hunter’ Sir Richard Topcliffe walked a challenging line between false joviality and harsher treatment as he attempted to force Southwell to give up the hiding places of his fellow Jesuits.

Unfortunately, despite the tense political setting and bloody subject matter of the show, many moments lacked tension. The dialogue was infused with facts and sometimes superfluous details about each of the characters’ biographical details, the intricacies of Jesuit beliefs, and the logistics of how different torture devices worked. While the play clearly demonstrates that Moore has read extensively on these subjects, the momentum of the narrative may have been better served by a stronger focus on the emotional worlds of the characters. Each of the show’s three characters spent time verbally analysing their own actions within the sociopolitical and historical landscape of early modern England’s religious tension, and every reference to a written work or other historical figure was explained (perhaps too clearly). The central aim of the play seemed to be to propose that Southwell was influential in Shakespeare’s choices to remain relatively uncontroversial in his politics; while it’s conceivable that the two writers met, and possibly likely that they read each other’s work, the theory that the two shared a close relationship does not have substantially convincing evidence behind it. A few historians have posited a link to a common ancestor between Southwell and Shakespeare seven generations back; one might argue that most people wouldn’t have any knowledge of or links to others with whom they shared a common ancestor seven generations ago, even considering the strengthened sense of kinship and lineage that many held in the early modern period.

This work explores an interesting time period, and offers an intriguing glimpse into the tragic end of a talented author. Despite the educational tone, the play did inspire a wish to explore Southwell’s poetry, and it may be a good introduction to the time period for those unfamiliar with the history. However, further revisions may be needed to refine the play’s momentum and impact.

What are your thoughts?