A play about pretending to be posh that feels like one big posh in-joke
Florence is a tidy one woman play. Writer and actor, Honor Santa Barnes, is on stage to tell us about the time she wanted a job in the art world so pretended to be a posh girl called Florence. After rave reviews at Edinburgh, it has transferred to London. The play feels Fringy: scant set (two black boxes); a high-energy performance (needed for a tired audience); and a few Dad jokes (that mostly land well).
Initially, Florence appears to be a play about elitism in the art world. Our nameless narrator has left Trinity Dublin with a first in History of Art but can’t get a job despite 47 job applications. To penetrate the industry she pretends to be Florence in order to befriend Isabella, an uber posh heiress who gives her access to social circles and confidence, which our nameless narrator feels she lacks. All is going well (apart from some dodgy art dealings) until the nameless narrator returns home to Ireland and finds she can’t leave Florence in London. Her childhood bedroom suddenly seems shabby; she’s become a snob. When she returns to London she magically gains a conscience, and rejects the Florence alter ego just in time for Isabella to catch up with her lies.
There are endless jokes about posh people – ‘Daddy cut me off’, ‘hunting shooting fishing is how I sell art’ – that feel more like caricature than satire. Instead of critiquing the affluent upper class Florence is from, Barnes only highlights its silliness. Doing so denies the play the chance to fully interrogate the social politics that make the art world so impenetrable. This is cemented when it transpires that Florence is not the only imagined character: our narrator has also been party girl Bethan from Wales and flirty girl Clare from Glasgow. The play morphs into being about the masks we wear to escape. If we’d spent more time with our nameless narrator – and understood what she was running from – we’d likely be more moved by this identity crisis.
Barnes has an arsenal of accents that she niftily uses to drive us through these different personas (unsure how she would have managed without) and some brilliant Gollum-esque moments, violently rotating her body. It is a pacy performance benefiting from good direction. Some of the jokes are over explained, sometimes it could with do a bit more show and a bit less tell (the best moments are when she reenacts interactions and stops describing feelings). But it isn’t hard to see why this show was a success. And if you like recognisably laughing at the upper class, you’re sure to love it.
Florence is on a Park Theatre until 21st November. Tickets here.

