Hammer blows and high spirits
At the Royal Festival Hall on Thursday 19 November, conductor Marin Alsop paired Bernstein’s Serenade, after Plato’s Symposium with Mahler’s Sixth Symphony. On paper it looked like a study in contrasts: a dinner-party debate on love, then one of the bleakest symphonies in the repertoire. In practice, it worked.
Alsop was Bernstein’s protégée, and her authority in the Serenade was clear from the first bars. She gave the piece a real sense of theatre, with each movement its own character and the overall shape never lost. Esther Yoo was an outstanding soloist, with a rich, expressive tone and total command of the score’s shifting moods. The highlight was her exchanges with the lower strings, which made the piece feel like a genuine conversation rather than a showcase. The writing is unmistakably Bernstein: lyrical passages tipping into rhythmic swagger, colourful percussion, and a jazzy warmth that cut in at exactly the right moments.
It’s a witty piece with more substance than its reputation suggests. Yoo’s recent album, Love
Symposium, is built around it, and this performance made a convincing case for the work. Mahler’s Sixth, though, was what most of the hall had come for. Alsop approached it with the seriousness and control it demands, and kept its minor-key severity firmly in place. The Scherzo was especially impressive, with commanding brass playing and a superb trumpet solo that stood out all evening. The recurring ideas gathered force as they passed between sections, and the Andante offered a welcome moment of calm before the Finale.
The Finale is a run of hopes that keep getting knocked down: a heroic horn, a gruff chorale, a fresh march, each one flattened by the same A major chord sliding into minor. Alsop kept that cycle moving without ever letting it slow. The tuba solo was a highlight, and the bells, placed out of sight stage left, lent the distance an unsettling edge. By the time the hammer finally fell, the tension had been so well judged that both blows cut straight through the noise, and you could see the audience jolt.
Alsop was a compelling presence throughout. Her conducting was energetic and physical, and at the music’s peaks her feet left the podium several times, a little jump as the melodies soared. The Philharmonia matched her with playing of real commitment, particularly in the more demanding passages of the Mahler. Bernstein supplied the wit and colour, Mahler the scale and tragedy. Alsop handled both with confidence, and the orchestra played superbly.
Alsop returns to the Royal Festival Hall with the Philharmonia in 2027 for Beethoven’s Ninth
Symphony on Thursday 22 April and Mahler’s First on Wednesday 12 May. Both should be
worth hearing.

