“Its framing of queer women ultimately begs the question: Who gets to tell what stories?”
Extraordinary Women, originally a novel written by Compton Mackenzie in the 1920s, is a story set on the fictional island of Sirene and follows a group of queer women’s love affairs. As one of the earliest mainstream English novels to center lesbian relationships, it was banned in the UK for obscenity due to its unapologetic portrayal of lesbianism.
The musical Extraordinary Women, currently performing at Jermyn Street Theatre, is an adaptation of this novel of the same name, featuring a brilliant ensemble with a majority-female cast. Sophie Louise Dann is utterly impeccable in all of her roles – fully believable, well-rounded, and hilariously funny. She gives a masterclass in characterization and comedy. Monique Young is also a force on stage, with a presence that is full of energy. The other ensemble members also deliver brilliant work in portraying multiple roles, giving the audience a peek into the different personalities of this group of queer women in the 1920s.
Extraordinary Women is, as defined by the characters themselves, a musical comedy. There are many punchy and witty lines that earn big laughs, and the show as a whole creates great comedic moments. However, it is questionable whether this story is the right choice for contemporary audiences. At the time of its publication, the novel was groundbreaking in its depiction of lesbian relationships. Yet, from a modern perspective, the story itself, as well as the satirical lens it casts on these queer women, could be seen as highly problematic.
The story centers around a playboy-esque woman who charms all the other women on the island, causing chaos. The depiction of the central figure, Rosalba (portrayed by Amy Ellen Richardson), feels like a gender-swapped male character rather than a fully realized woman. Under the direction, the character’s costumes – she is the only one wearing blazers and jumpsuits throughout the show, while all other female characters wear dresses – along with her demeanor (constantly leaning on the wall, hands always in her pockets) – and even the character’s construction (a “womanizer” who pursues multiple love interests and cheats on her partner) – align closely with a classic playboy archetype. Although the character was based on real historical figures, it’s doubtful whether this depiction humanizes them or simply reinforces a male archetype.
The story also fails to add depth to its characters. The storytelling is fragmented – scenes are composed of small pieces of dialogue and underdeveloped character realizations. Hardly any character undergoes an arc. Given these flaws, the title “Extraordinary Women” – repeatedly mentioned in the show – feels less like a genuine descriptor and more like a satirical commentary on these women. The story was, admittedly, written by a man. But in the 21st century, do we really need more stories about women written through a male gaze?
While the musical delivers sharp comedy and standout performances, its framing of queer women ultimately begs the question: Who gets to tell what stories?
Extraordinary Women runs at Jermyn Street Theatre until 10th August. Tickets are available here.









