REVIEW: For the Love of Trees


Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

arboreal and musical storytelling


May 5th saw the show at Edinburgh TradFest split in two halves – a set from avant folk vocalist and composer Fiona Soe Paing, followed by this year’s special commission “For The Love of Trees” created by harpist, singer and composer Mary Macmaster. 

Set in the darkness of the Traverse Theatre, Fiona Soe Paing’s set took us through songs from her audio-visual show, “SAND, SILT, FLINT“, tying folklore from the North East of Scotland with alt-folk electronica ballads, against an arresting audiovisual backdrop.  

Over seven songs from her album, Fiona projected an ethereal performance, with her haunting vocals supplemented by archive sound recordings, and backing track. At times, this track felt close to to overwhelming her voice, blurring the lines between what was live and what was recorded, which could have been off-putting in other hands but added to the other-worldly air. The underlying almost industrial synthesising adding extra texture, and almost disconcerting emotion.  

Behind her, we were gliding over locations on an old map of Aberdeenshire, before being overlaid by swooping drone footage over various landscapes, ruins, castles, coastlines and hills, befitting the particular song.  The involvement of the audio-visual element added an extra dimension, but at times was almost too bewitching, distracting from the performance in front of us. Personal favourites of the songs included the darker stories – “Forvie” the tale of a village swallowed by a nine-day sandstorm, after being cursed by three daughters, and the ill-fated romance of “Tifty’s Annie”. I’d have loved to have heard more about the underlying folklore for all of these tales, had time permitted.  

Following a short break, we moved on Mary Macmaster’s commission piece, “For The Love Of Trees”, with a 10 song set combining traditional tunes with modern compositions, all on the subject of trees, and their link to the Celtic cultures of Scotland and Ireland. 

In the accompanying programme, and in short interludes for tuning breaks, we learned more about the inspiration for some of the songs – particularly those inspired by recent cultural events, such as the felling of the tallest tree in Edinburgh’s Botanic Gardens due to Storm Éowyn, and the trial of the Sycamore cut down at Hadrian’s Wall. 

On stage with Mary (who played electric harp, clàrsach, and sang) were a band comprising of Pete Harvey (cello), Amy Macdougall (vocals), Mairearad Green (accordion and bagpipes), Ciaran Ryan (guitar, fiddle and banjo) and Donald Hay (percussion, including bird and wood recordings). 

The performances from the band were excellent, and the melding of instruments worked well together. Having the pipes as the first song is a bold choice (and it’s always bold to have pipes played indoors, such is the volume produced!) but the way the melodies built over time, adding layers to the harp gave a harmonious air. However, at times the vocal performances felt a little out of sync, which is maybe a natural reaction to not having sung together much before.

The electric harp is fabulous instrument in Mary’s hands, but the effect of the clàrsach in the penultimate tune “Cumha Crann nan Teud: Lament for the Tree of Strings” was exceptional.  

The songs were accompanied by high resolution images of trees, from interesting perspectives (for example, close-up shots of lichen, tree knots, and branching elements) but in contrast to the high drama of Fiona Soe Paing’s AV, this felt a little flat in comparison. The images were of amazing quality, but were on a long-ish loop, so there was a sense of deja vu as the set progressed, and images reappeared. It might have invoked a stronger emotional connection if the images were tied more closely to the songs and their lyrics – it felt a little strange on the dying notes of “Rowan” to have holly leaves shown. Similarly, I was expecting to see the evocative broken Cedar tree in “The Cedar, Silent” and the now-felled Sycamore from “Sycamore Gap”.  

With a rousing rendition of Pulp’s “The Trees”, the evening drew to a close, and to warm appreciation from the crowd. Taken as a whole, the evening was a pleasurable insight into how non-traditional traditional music can be, with the two performances complementing each other well with their differences as well as their similarities.

Edinburgh TradFest runs from 2nd – 12th May 2025. For more details, please see: https://edinburghtradfest.com/  

REVIEW: The Night Overtook Us


Rating: 5 out of 5.

“A lively, evocative exploration of winter in the Scottish Highlands, with a stunning new piece from composer Donald Grant.”


This weekend saw composer and violinist Donald Grant premiere a new work in London: Thuit an Oidhche Oirnn (The Night Overtook Us). The piece was performed by Grant and his band with the local Aurora Orchestra as part of a concert exploring the harshness and beauty of winter in the Scottish Highlands. With a varied yet cohesive programme, the evening was an exciting blend of traditional melodies with new writing and creative new arrangements.

The concert opened with a traditional tune from Grant’s hometown of Roybridge – “A Mhairead Óg,” and then under soft washes of light, the rest of the ensemble entered with modern composer David Fennessy’s Hirta Rounds. Inspired by Hirta, the largest of the islands in St. Kilda, this evocative and haunting piece had light, dancing notes fluttering over sustained, droning chords. The strings conversed in a sort of harmonic chaos reminiscent of sounds echoing down a glen, a chorus of birdsong, or rain pattering into a lake.

The next pieces saw the tempo pick up, as the band took centre stage for Calum Stewart’s Am Monadh Ruadh, evoking the mountains known as the Cairngorms today, and Donald Grant’s own piece To the West, inspired by his childhood camping holidays on the coastlines overlooking the Inner Hebrides. Grant’s arrangement of Am Monadh Ruadh was beautifully balanced, drawing on the combined power of the band and ensemble while still allowing each instrument their moments to shine. With swelling strings and some slightly jazzier stylings on the piano, this tune had the audience tapping their toes from the start, and To the West kept the energy up with a bluesy, bluegrass-esque jig, which drew out the rhythmic and tonal elements of traditional Scottish tunes which have shaped these more modern genres.

Next, Scottish folk singer Mischa MacPherson led the ensemble in “An Robh thu sa Bheinn,” a wool-waulking song; these work songs are usually led by the eldest woman in the group as a call-and-response chant to keep the group working the wool in time. Grant’s arrangement added a driving beat to the melody, resulting in a rock-and-roll energy enhanced by dynamic red lighting onstage. MacPherson then lent her talents to “Ailean Dubh,” a love song about an admittedly problematic raider who has captured a woman’s heart. With simpler piano and sustained strings, Grant’s setting allowed MacPherson’s dynamic and graceful vocals to shine. For Ailie Robertson’s string trio, The Black Pearl, some of the other musicians sat or stood around the back of the stage, lending an easy, communal atmosphere to this jazzy piece which added a more driving, suspenseful tone to the programme. La Bottine Souriante’s Prelude Valse was a catchy, swinging waltz, and a nod to the Scottish roots of traditional Québécois music.

Donald Grant’s new composition, Thuit an Oidhche Oirnn (The Night Overtook Us), was a true highlight of the evening. Grant drew some inspiration from winter’s elemental brutality, such as one 19th-century storm in Roybridge described by local John MacPhee, which hit like a flash in the middle of the day and wreaked havoc on the community. Alongside this intensity, Grant also wished to capture the culture of communities working together to bring light, warmth, and music into the longest nights, and chose to honour the siskin (a.k.a. pìobaire, or ‘piper’) as a symbol of this hope, as this bright yellow bird stays each winter in Scotland and can serve as a reminder of more colourful times to come. With delicate trills on the violin over a steady beat from the double bass, the piece eased into a waltz, with soaring strings and sunny melodies. A more haunting, traditional tune shifted the energy of the piece, as the rhythmic guitar started to conjure images of a rising storm, and Grant was able to show off some impressively quick fingers and dynamic phrasing on the violin as the piece built to an energetic finish with resounding applause.

MacPherson returned for another love song with “Dohmnull Nan Domhnull,” bringing a delicate warmth and tenderness to the melody, and the evening was brought to a jolly close with Grant’s The Way Home. This concert was a varied yet cohesive modern folk programme, and a brilliant exploration of the joy to be found in blending historic and modern tunes, tones, and stylings.

Thuit an Oidhche Oirnn (The Night Overtook Us) was performed on September 28th at Kings Place.

REVIEW: Simon & Garfunkel Through The Years In Concert


Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Music to make your soul hurt and your body tingle


Capital Theatres played host this week to what could be the closest thing we can get in 2024 to a live performance from folk music legends, Simon and Garfunkel.

Dan Haynes and Pete Richards bring an outstandingly accurate tribute and celebration of the duo’s lives and music. Through excellent musicianship, sympathetic arrangements and voices that simultaneously lull you to sleep and bring you tears.

When I closed my eyes, I believed I was listening to my mum’s copy of Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme.With careful use of an additional guitarist, violin, viola and cello, the sound from the stage was fully rounded and utterly balanced. Minimalistic lighting and staging let this talented pair rely on their sumptuous tone and let the music do the talking. 

 That said, where tribute acts often fall down in their audience banter between songs, Haynes and Richards have no troubled waters to traverse. Peppering the audience with interesting nuggets of Paul and Art social history with a perfectly rehearsed ease. What was really nice to see during the second half was that the stories shifted to their own stories of meeting in college and bonding over a mutual love of music while skipping classes. This is a pair perfectly comfortable on the stage and by each others sides and you can believe these two are true friends.

While this show might not have appealed to a younger audience with the average age in the auditorium sitting at mid 50s, I would (as a 32 year old young-ish perspective) urge my peers to experience this show when they can. I only mention this as the gentleman sat beside me actually commented on the fact he didn’t know people my age knew about the artists! While Simon and Garfunkel may have been most popular in the 60s and 70s, this is folk music at its finest that speaks to all ages as the songs were written from Paul and Art from adolescence through the ups and downs of adult life. Truly inspired song construction, lyrics to make your soul hurt and harmonies that send a tingle from scalp to toes. Having only ever been able to listen to the original music recordings before, it was a magical experience to get to enjoy this music live and done so exquisitely.

REVIEW: Come Together: The Lennon and McCartney Songbook

Rating: 5 out of 5.

The next best thing to seeing The Beatles live, this show is a triumph and a joy for any fan

Obviously, I never got to see The Beatles live. I’m sure very few, if any, of the audience tonight did, since they split up in 1970. But I feel being present at this performance was the closest I’ll ever get: it was a truly special night leaving me uplifted and inspired.

An optional pre-show meal was served at your cabaret-style table in the stalls. It was a charming and quirky setting for a delicious meal as we settled into our seats waiting for the show to begin, and a playlist of 60s music set the scene for a night to remember.

As soon as the curtain rose, we were put at ease and I felt immediately confident I was going to enjoy myself. The show was of course mainly music, but it followed the story of Lennon and McCartney as they wrote songs together and their styles developed. Tom Connor and Mark Newnham were the perfect Paul and John. Tom particularly looked strikingly like Paul McCartney, but their voices were both very accurate to the iconic sounds. Their acting, singing and playing of multiple instruments was incredible and they were magnetic to watch. They were accompanied by four other musicians who also played with energy and charisma. It was so interesting and very cleverly written, intertwining the stories with the songs and using the set and backing screen to set the scene. 

As the youngest person in the audience by quite a long way, I probably have a different perspective of The Beatles to everyone else. However, it struck me that regardless, we all grew up listening to this music. It’s a true testament to the quality of the band.

The double standing ovation was highly deserved. I watched my fellow audience members enthralled, holding their torches aloft and swaying, singing along and clapping and knew they too had been transported back in time. I can’t commend the musicians enough. They were not only extremely well-rehearsed so the whole thing was seamless, but also talented enough to showcase Lennon and McCartney’s abilities as musicians. I would also like to praise the sound and lighting which were both on point.

At the interval, we were served our desserts, which was another layer to the high standard of the evening. If you attend, please do sample the African doughnuts or chocolate orange bread and butter pudding. 

I particularly enjoyed the storytelling element throughout; it was engaging but the bulk of it was music, meaning they were able to perform many of the iconic songs including ‘Yesterday’, ‘Come Together’, ‘Let it Be’ and ‘I Wanna Hold Your Hand’. There was a part I loved where they sang in three European languages to show the fanbase spreading, but for me, the stand-out moment was ‘Hey Jude’. The whole audience were as one, singing out loud, celebrating the groundbreaking music of Lennon and McCartney, here in their hometown of Liverpool.

REVIEW: Sam Lee ‘songdreaming’


Rating: 5 out of 5.

A standout example of the ‘new folk’ genre and the universality of music.


As the second stop on his new album’s extensive UK tour, Sam Lee took to Edinburgh’s Summerhall in celebration of his fourth studio album ‘songdreaming.’ With a beautiful opening by singer songwriter Finn Anderson and a set of new and old hits, the performance was infinitely likeable. Soft spoken and personable, Sam Lee was a barefooted breath of fresh air on the stage. There was a somberness to the performance that was totally entrancing and utterly enigmatic from beginning to end. Inspiring a fanbase that exceeds all expectation and generational divide, the crowd comprised a delightful mix of respectful and attentive patrons giving the whole affair an air of reverence and meditation. 

Regarding the set itself, Sam’s work, comprising four albums, is utterly cinematic—which is fitting seeing as the newest album was mostly written for the screen. Epical in every sense, it posed not only an astounding contrast to the quirky singer, himself, but also the lovely juxtaposition of fantastical and temporal themes. Encompassing a wide range of experience and tone, it was a real treat to hear the inspiration and history that brought it all about. Giving new life to old tunes and bringing them into the public awareness as living history is a laudable and mammoth endeavor that Sam appears to take into stride. Quick to recognize the subtext and lingering unease inherent in all his songs, the set was evocative of nature and the human connection to it with its seemingly dwindling partnership. Eco-anxiety notwithstanding it was stunning, inspiring, and downright good.

A beautiful collaborative endeavour produced by Bernard Butler and composer James Keay, the evening was an overall success and a privilege to be a part of, especially in such an intimate space. It is always a lovely surprise to hear new music that steps outside of popular themes and narratives, and it was obvious by the eclectic and packed turnout that there is an audience craving simple and cerebral sounds. Deserving of every bit of critical acclaim the album and performance has amassed already, simply put: it was quirky, it was fun. It was unexpected and it sets the bar high for the oxymoronic ‘new folk’ sound.

Tickets are now on sale, visit www.samleesong.co.uk for details and booking.