A slick, frenetic scratch night blending a bizarre array of stories
Chaos at the Pleasance Theatre is an innovative and slick version of a scratch night. From Long Nights Productions (Jack Medlin, Theo Collins, and Sarah Chamberlain), Chaos consists of nine performances, blended together, in a cabaret-esque setting. It’s certainly ambitious, and it’s unusual, even for a scratch night.
Naturally, given its context as a scratch night, the pieces themselves vary drastically in quality. It’s a little challenging to comment on the overall theatrical experience because each piece is so disparate from the others; the challenge is to shield yourself from the tonal whiplash. And there’s no unifying theme – despite chaos, I suppose – but chaos is not a conceit in and of itself.
The show opens with one woman pouring vodka into a carton of orange juice, before she is harassed by the door, and watches as two women drag in a body bag. Quickly, the stage setup is pushed about, and so begins a piece about a child and an obsessive neighbour (also a child). At some point, a monologue was delivered from the perspective of a vengeful Scottish toilet. Then we were whisked to the peak of a mountain where a bunch of queer youths stood in line for a Berghain-esque club, just with the added peril of being atop a mountain. There was also some attempt at Clown concerning a series of backpacks.
Some of the writing was accomplished: I enjoyed Barney Doran and Anna Fenton-Garvey’s performance and writing as the ruthless non-binary clubbers. And the four women sharing pastries in their hostage situation was a highlight. However, as an overall theatrical event, it struggles to captivate. Without any perceptible binding conceit, it’s a struggle to invest yourself in any of the pieces or gain any sense of pattern recognition. And in the absence of thematic unity, the context of ‘chaos’ loses any architectural meaning.
I would probably argue that not everything is a theatrical opportunity (see: the Scottish toilet – he kills his male philandering owner in a self-righteous fury). There was also an ethically dubious piece about an Italian restaurateur’s Japanese wife who turned out to be a lifeless doll.
The set design (Geneve Chu) is commendable; the transitions are smooth, and the space is imaginatively understood. For a scratch night, it is extremely organised; it’s reassuringly structured. The band (LA Family Trio) is a fun accompaniment, and the lighting (Aaron Molloy) is well deployed. But the pieces themselves – and the organising concept – fail to engage and lack the satisfaction of a more conventional piece of theatre. As a scratch night, of course, the intention is not to create one unified story, but it is a struggle to care about any of the stories or characters within this setup.










