Stephen Smith wrestles with a trio of spooky tales from the original goth-in-chief, clearing a few stumbling blocks to deliver a gleeful homage to all things murder and mayhem.
‘Nervous!’ declares our narrator upon rising from his pre-show state of mute mental anguish. ’Very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?’ And here we are in Edgar Allen Poe’s world: where sanity and safety are fleeting memories, and darkness reigns supreme. Actor-director Stephen Smith takes on three short tales – The Tell-Tale Heart, The Pit and the Pendulum, and The Raven – in an endurance blitz that goes for the nerves and sets its sights on dragging us into as palpable a rendering of the Poeverse as it can.
Smith has immediately made a striking gambit with this theatricalisation, cleaving meticulously to Poe’s language for the piece’s dialogue, and – as far as I could divine – leaving the tales entirely unedited and unredacted. “I honoured the texts as one would Shakespeare’s,” he avows in the director’s notes, along with his intention to deliver them “as faithfully as can be.” Setting aside the question of who ‘one’ is in this figuration – or if strict adherence is the only or best way a text can be honoured – it’s clear that One Man Poe is, at heart, a celebration and a veneration, over and above any sort of distinctive rearticulation of the author’s ideas and imagery. Smith is operating in the anti-mode of Mike Flanagan, whose modernised melange of Poeian characters and tropes The Fall of the House of Usher hit Netflix a couple of years back.
But what’s surprising in some ways is that it’s precisely this straightforward, devotional angle of approach that becomes perhaps the triptych’s greatest strength. It’s so obvious throughout every moment of One Man Poe that Smith just really, really loves this stuff. He dives into these maniacal, tortured, haunted characters with the electric verve of a D&D Dungeon Master with a huge budget and no day job. The elasticity of his vocal and facial work has a welcome dynamism, and he has a natural ease with the text that makes the whole evening fluent and extremely watchable. Shades of each of these characters can be a little overcooked and grotesque; the narrator in The Tell-tale Heart invites us to “observe how healthily—how calmly I can tell you the whole story”, but Smith’s seething, twitching (undeniably entertaining) eccentrics don’t leave much madness to the imagination. He also makes a serious misstep in the rendering of The Raven’s grief-addled narrator, leaning far too heavily into a decrepit-old-man caricature, and stripping the poem of some of its eerie solemnity.
Technical elements in the piece are executed with deft aplomb. Lighting (uncredited in the programme, but likely by the Jack’s theatre manager Karl Swinyard) is brash, lush and unsettling all at once. He makes shadows as much a feature of the images as light, offsetting velveteen purples and blues with creeping dark – all through the luxurious density of macabre haze effects. Joseph Furey and Django Holder’s sound design is sculpted and fine-tuned to perfection, with a puckish humour to its rhythm that breathes in tempo with the performance; the spatial mixing is particularly clever and cunningly handled – it’s enough to make you shiver or chuckle in its own right. Furey also gets latitude to stretch out into some expansive music, which is gorgeously composed (some minorly kitschy horns notwithstanding). The set is a peculiar element to consider here: a bulky collection of furniture items is bundled off to the side of the space, the facsimile of an austere 1800s sitting-room. But it’s rarely engaged with at all by Smith, aside from once as a temporary seat and sporadically as a repository for props, which makes it a little vexing to parse in the fabric of the performance beyond a spectral evocation of the author’s own habitus.
But here’s the main hitch: Smith’s obeisance to Poe’s original text necessarily positions the whole performance (sometimes generatively, sometimes tenuously) somewhere between a radio-play/audio-book and a stage adaptation. While the author’s prolixity is undoubtedly an engine of excitement, it also manifests in performance as an abundance of verbiage, which occasionally forces Smith into a dramaturgical corner (pit?) wherein the theatre of it all sort of… freezes. And we’re left only with a rousing dramatic recitation of a short story in relative stasis. These are the sequences in which the show suddenly feels as though it’s treading water for a while, waiting for the script to reach a point that the team felt could be rendered as a holistic theatricalised moment.
Granted: it’s a finicky point to make, given the high degree of difficulty here and the reality that one story involves the narrator being literally strapped to a table for a large portion of it. Lucky thing then that, overwhelmingly, Smith’s gusto, tactility, energy, mnemonic gymnastics and – yes – love are enough to keep us along for the ride. It’s good, clean, spooky fun, and a crisp night at the theatre.






