A technically brilliant performance that lacked staying power
The Scottish Chamber Orchestra Chorus and Kana Kawashima brought a beautiful holiday concert to the magnificent Grayfriers Kirk this week. The programme offered an intriguing blend of traditional and contemporary works, celebrating the season with a thoughtful selection of pieces. Performed in the atmospheric Greyfriars Kirk, the venue provided a fittingly intimate and acoustically vibrant setting for the Scottish Chamber Orchestra Chorus and Kana Kawashima’s violin interludes.
Highlights of the concert included Vaughan Williams’s “The Truth from Above”, which set a reflective and understated tone, and Judith Weir’s “Drop down, ye heavens”, evoking a serene sense of mystery. Tavener’s “Hymn to the Mother of God” brought a sense of cosmic depth, its rich harmonies resonating powerfully in the space, while Howells’s “A Spotless Rose” was a poignant nod to the beauty and purity of the season. These moments showcased the ensemble’s technical precision and control, which were consistently evident throughout the performance.
Kana Kawashima’s violin solos, such as Bach’s “Largo from Sonata No. 3 in C”, were technically flawless, highlighting her exceptional skill. However, while her playing was impeccable, it sometimes lacked emotional warmth, leaving these interludes feeling more like exhibitions of technical brilliance than moments of heartfelt reflection. Similarly, the chorus performed with exceptional clarity and cohesion, but their delivery often felt restrained, missing opportunities to convey deeper passion and expressive intensity that might have drawn the audience more fully into the music’s emotional heart.
The new arrangement of “Silent Night” by Lucy Walker, while a commendable effort, did not entirely achieve its intended impact. As the concert’s centerpiece, it carried the weight of expectation to provide a moment of profound emotional resonance, but the arrangement felt subdued, unable to evoke the familiar carol’s full depth of feeling.









