Carrie meets Heather’s meets The Pick of Destiny, this show is bonkers!
I Was A Teenage She-Devil really exemplifies the wonderfully mad spirit of The Other Palace. A Theatre known for putting on shows that break the mould or are a little out there in nature, this crazy 80s-inspired musical fits the bill.
The best word to describe this musical is bonkers. It’s absolutely wild in every conceivable way, and that’s exactly what makes it work. Sometimes, in fact, more often than not, things that are trying to be 80s don’t work as intended. Either because they try so hard it feels inauthentic, or they just don’t capture the magic of the era. This stands out because it fully leans into itself. Into the madness, the 80s tropes, the cringe and the iconic. It knows it’s insane and fully embraces it, usually in very funny ways. Most importantly, it doesn’t take itself too seriously. It fully recognises that the era it lives in is full of melodrama and goofy energy, both in the films it pays homage to and the music. It captures the romance and the teen angst, but also isn’t afraid to make fun of itself. It takes thoughts you’ve had about every 80s movie, like “why does this high school student look like they could have a mortgage and kids of their own?”, and fully presents it to you through humour, with the reveal that Rod, the jock who looks way too old to still be in education, is in fact 35 years old.
It has fun with all these tropes, the jock who’s a total jerk, the popular mean girl head cheerleader who goes out with him and the glasses-wearing loser girl who just wants to fit in. We know them all because they’re classic (if somewhat overused) themes of virtually every single film from that decade. Then we have the best friend who’s in love with the protagonist, but this is where the use of these labels gets interesting, as it becomes this queer love story with Debbie having a crush on her best friend Nancy, the story’s “loser girl”. In the 80s, people often weren’t bold enough to tell stories of this nature, so it’s nice to see how well it can work for the time period.
The narrative of this musical then gets a bit nuts and adds Satan in. Having been humiliated by head cheerleader Tiffani and boyfriend Rod following an incident in which Tiffani is banned from homecoming and kicked off the cheer squad by the gym teacher, this part of the plot possibly sounds familiar as being more or less the story of Carrie. However, the show being as self-aware as it is points this out through the character of Doobie, resident film expert and manager of the video store. After the humiliation, this is where the Heathers aspects come in. “Nancy’s Lament”, a short emotional number where she sings of how she’d sell her soul for love, leads to the sudden appearance of the devil. Naturally, she is given exactly what she wishes for, but is also turned into a she-devil. She then proceeds to punish her classmates for their wrongdoings. Nancy is like a cross between Veronica and J.D. from the cult classic. If it wasn’t already crazy, Debbie challenges Satan to a rock-off for Nancy’s soul. We go pretty far from the 80s here, as this is essentially the plot of Tenacious D In The Pick of Destiny. It’s a mashup of wild proportions and the sort of mix that maybe feels like it shouldn’t work, but somehow, it just does.
The music helps greatly with that and is across the board, intrinsically 80s. When it comes to the voices behind it, they’re nothing short of perfection. The vocals from this cast are so powerful, so strong that it makes the atmosphere of the whole performance feel absolutely epic! Ashley Goh as Debbie really embodied that rock vibe from start to finish, especially when she sings about her feelings for Nancy in “Lookin’ For Love”. Aoife Haakenson goes from loser girl to succubus she-devil in a transformation that appears effortless. The talent was unreal as we see her change from the girl who wants love and acceptance in “I Wanna Be Someone’s Girlfriend”, a girl who is far more timid and less sure of herself, to this extraordinary demonic creature in songs like “She-Devil”, where she has much more agency over herself. Haakenson’s She-Devil felt akin to Jim Carrey in The Mask when she speaks, and it felt right, like that was exactly how she should sound. It was brilliant!
Overall, this musical’s mad energy is fuelled by passion, fun and outrageous talent from everyone involved. It’s only at The Other Palace for a limited run, so be sure not to miss it! You’ll have a hell of a time.
This show runs at The Other Palace till 26th April. Tickets available here.









