goosebumps and intrigue
Ali Milles’ chilling thriller “The Croft” is a story of many elements – part Scottish folklore, part real-life history, part family drama, combined with love, grief, violence, hatred, and ripples of consequences from past decisions.
The play, directed by Alastair Whatley, unfolds in an old crofter’s hut in Coillie Ghillie – a deserted village in the Highlands, out of reach of the rest of humanity. Laura (played by Gracie Follows) and Suzanne (Caroline Harker) arrive after a long drive up from England, and over the course of a few days, and amidst unexpected events, a tangle of threads emerges from past and present lives connected with the croft. We hear Coillie Ghillie described as ancient, and a ruin built on a ruin, that you need to feel in your blood to be welcome within.
Laura and Suzanne’s weekend unfolds with the stories of Laura’s parents, Ruth (Caroline Harker), Tom (Simon Roberts), and the local ghillie David Ross (Gray O’Brien); and that of a far older history, dating back to 1970s, with Enid (Liza Goddard) on the verge of eviction following claims of witchcraft and blasphemy, and Eileen (Gracie Follows) who’s ultimate fate was never understood.
Much of the focus is on Laura and Suzanne’s storyline, and their interactions with David, who knew Laura as a child. The performances are solid, and there are moments of comic levity peppered throughout to offset tenser moments, frequently delivered in a typically Highland deadpan manner by David, such as crowning Suzanne “the banshee from Barnet”. Although there are distinctly Scottish undertones, there is sufficient exposition provided to make it understandable for those not familiar with folklore. A noted example being the “Selkie vs Selfie” conversation, between the three. Gracie’s portrayal of Laura is wonderful, however, it felt at times the character was veering on the more petulant side. As the play progressed into the second act, (and without spoiling anything!) some of the parallels in the relationship felt a little over-emphasised.
With the set being a deceptively simple cut through of the croft’s living room, the onus is on the actors to denote the different characters they play, and they change cleanly and rapidly, often as we watch them on stage, with something as simple as whirl of a shawl. The lighting design by Chris Davey, is especially evocative, with no additional light from the house lights, the on-stage lighting created a deeper intimacy in the changing storylines.
This is not a play with a continuous string of jump-scares, but there are some genuinely spooky moments in Act 1, and this increases in Act 2, as the tension ramps up, and I had definite goosebumps as it reached the climax of the play. Judging by the audience reactions around me, others felt the same way, with sharp intakes of breath and rapt attention.
However, the story of the croft is more than a ghost story – much like David notes when comparing spirits and ghosts, it is more complex. The story culminates in a satisfying conclusion of the various threads, but the characters remain with you, long after the show.
The Coille Ghillie may not be in your blood, but everyone looking for a tale of relationships with chills and intrigue should consider heading for “The Croft”.
The Croft runs at Edinburgh’s Festival Theatre from Wednesday 25th – Saturday 28th June 2025. For tickets, see: https://www.capitaltheatres.com/shows/the-croft/











