A stilted, numbed showcase of what orchestral performance shouldn’t be
Orchestral music is constantly in pursuit of reinvention; for something that will maintain its relevance and unlock the interests of new audiences. There is no doubt there isn’t much that can capture awe like a live orchestra, but with digital consumption of music the mainstream, developing new ways of experiencing the live orchestral experience is essential to keep it alive. This is exactly what heavyweights of the orchestral music world like the BBC Philharmonic attempt to do.
For one night (and matinee) only, the orchestra took up a residency in Aviva Studios, arguably the most exciting, ambitious, and versatile venues in Manchester. Performing a myriad of pieces (from Swan Lake to Anna Clyne via Greensleeves) in the venue’s sprawling South Warehouse, the performance’s second half included the world premiere of Clyne’s new work PALETTE. This used Augmented Orchestra (AO), a compositional technology developed by Clyne herself, which we learnt enhances the live sound with direct responses to the orchestra’s tone, dynamics and more via a sound engineer.
In the first half, we see John Adam’s ‘A Short Ride in a Fast Machine’ which provides a palatable and bitesize beginning to the show. However, it isn’t until Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake that we are witness to the Philharmonic’s prowess. Although this is some of the most dynamic and beautiful music ever, it is still a pleasure to see such proficient musicians perform it. This is followed by Vaughan William’s take on Greensleeves and then Thomas Adès’ Dante opera in a setlist described as extraordinary but far too ranged to provide any sort of cohesion. Instead of enjoying each piece for its merits, I was met with musical whiplash by the jumps across centuries.
The orchestra were laid out in three elevated sections with walkways and audience spaces dissecting them. The audience were encouraged to walk as close as they could to the musicians, which, to its merit, did deconstruct the conventions of orchestral performance. However, it was too cramped a space with too many uncomfortable shuffles to enjoy a fluid promenade-style performance. Couple this with the awkward (or, in some cases, terrified) eyes shot at us from the musicians, this innovation was rendered futile. The conductor took his position on a raised plinth in full view of each section, which meant we as an audience found ourselves dropped almost amidst the musicians, and it was difficult to resist the intrusive urge to stand in-between the conductor and musicians’ eyelines, in turn derailing the entire performance.
The lighting design was simple, with various washes and spotlights of block colours illuminating sections of the warehouse. The sound design was imbalanced, which was the point, and this did effectively contribute to the interesting dissection of orchestral sections. I wish the performance had used projection or at least some form of video design, as a main selling point of the publicity was the paintings Anna Clyne had done alongside her new composition. These were consigned to the outside screens as we queued and had no impact on the actual performance. With a venue that no doubt had the capability to accommodate for projection, these being screened while the orchestra played would have provided an intriguing extra dynamic.
It was this lack of ambition that hamstringed the performance for me. Aviva Studios has such versatility, and it wasn’t used at all. If the event had been more daring it would have achieved a leap forward in orchestral performance that would have felt refreshing to a regular visitor to these kinds of events, and exciting for newcomers. Instead, we saw a stilted, numbed showcase of what orchestra performance shouldn’t be – dull, uninventive, and safe.









